Marriage – Is a Second Marriage Valid?

2 min read

A recent case in the Family Court of Australia considered the situation where a woman, Ms Kirvan, had married twice, and therefore whether the second marriage was valid.

Ms Kirvan initially married Mr D in 2015 while overseas. She then moved to Australia on a student visa in March 2016. While it appears the initial plan was for Mr D to follow Ms Kirvan to Australia, unfortunately their relationship broke down shortly thereafter and Mr D’s visa application was refused due to him being no longer in a spousal relationship with Ms Kirvan.

Ms Kirvan commenced proceedings to divorce Mr D, however, there was a delay in Mr D being served with the required Court documents, and so the divorce did not move ahead as quickly as Ms Kirvan had hoped.

Once in Australia, Ms Kirvan met and moved in with Mr Tomaras in about March 2017. Ms Kirvan and Mr Tomaras were concerned about the cultural integrity of their cohabitation in that they were living together but unmarried. They were aware that Ms Kirvan had not formally divorced from Mr D but felt that the “marriage was not valid any longer”. They therefore decided to marry.

The marriage took place in mid-2017, but Ms Kirvan’s divorce from Mr D was not granted by Court order until 22 October 2017.

Under Australian law, it is illegal to marry someone while already married to another person. Section 94 of the Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) provides “A person who is married shall not go through a form or ceremony of marriage with any person”, with a possible penalty of 5 years’ imprisonment. It is therefore a criminal offence and a person can be charged and be sentenced to jail if found guilty.

The Judge considered that Ms Kirvan’s marriage to Mr D was valid and recognised in Australia, despite having occurred in another country.

As a result, the Judge found that the marriage between Ms Kirvan and Mr Tomaras was not valid and declared that it was a nullity. The Judge also referred the matter to the relevant authorities so that they could prosecute Ms Kirvan and Ms Tomaras for their crimes if they chose to do so.

It is unclear whether Ms Kirvan and Mr Tomaras had actually separated or were still in a relationship and whether this was therefore an attempt to get in front of any immigration and visa issues that may have arisen as a result of their invalid marriage, particularly as Mr Tomaras considered that Ms Kirvan’s solicitor acted for both of them in the Court proceedings.

While divorce may seem like a mere formality after the breakdown of a relationship and quite minor in the context of property and parenting issues, it is important to ensure that you are formally divorced before marrying another person. It is not uncommon for people to remain married many years after their relationship has broken down. Divorce proceedings can take many months to come to a resolution, particularly if the parties have children together or the other party does not agree to the divorce. The passage of time can also create issues if the parties have fallen out of touch as the application will need to be served on the person’s husband or wife before it is considered by the Court. Further, once the Court considers the application and grants the divorce, the divorce will not become final until 1 month and 1 day after.

If you require assistance with a divorce application, we are able to assist. Please contact us to speak to someone about your matter.

Kirvan & Tomaras [2018] FamCA 171 (21 March 2018)

Loading

Loading

Picture of Authored By<br>Jennifer Jennings

Authored By
Jennifer Jennings

Director Lawyer, PBL Law Group

Find what you need
Share this Article

Book a 15-Min Consultation​

Rated 5-Star By Our Clients

Jye Hall
Anita Bradley has been an absolute dream to deal with. Anita's conveyancing skills and knowledge knows absolutely no boundaries along with her effective communication skills which has made selling and buying a completely stress free exchange for us. We recommend PBL Law to everyone looking for outstanding service. We will definitely be returning clients.
Kushlan Aluwihare
PBL Law Group were fantastic. Anita from PBL worked with us closely during our property search and made the exchange and settlement process smooth and stress free. Highly recommended.
Gail Whitford
PBL handled my late mothers estate, they were very obliging and patient with any and all questions that we had, thank you to David , Sharon and the other staff that we dealt with, everyone was so easy to talk to and friendly .David came to the home where my Mother was living and helped her to get her will in order, Sharon helped us through the process of executing her wishes when the time came even doing a house call which was so much easier, thank you all so much
S M
I have experienced an excellent service from PBL (especially from Anita) during the sale of my recent property on Central Coast, and during the purchase of our current property in Sydney. Throughout many challengers, especially with the sale, Anita presented her very professional and knowledgeable conveyancer, positively solving all obstacles. "Above and Beyond" Award going to Anita!!! :-)
Amanda Reitzin
The five-star reviews are well-deserved. I needed a motion and a bylaw drawn up for urgent repairs of my strata unit and the AGM was in two weeks' time. My solicitor was friendly, efficient, knew what documents to ask for, and had all the paperwork prepared well within the timeframe. She also took the time to run through all the legalese and the different possible scenarios with me to make sure I understood. I am so glad to have found this firm and I will not hesitate to use their services again in future if the need arises.
Ricky Cooper
Anita is amazing! So attentive, approachable and communicates everything every step of the way. I have now bought and sold property with Anita and I cannot recommend her highly enough.
Ron Thomsen
Our Commercial Property conveyancing was handled very professionally. Anita’s experience and responsiveness was an asset in this transaction.
Trace M
I am so grateful for Anita Bradley from PBL Law Group helped me with this property settlement, she has went above beyond to ensure I understand everything because of our deafness. I will recommended Anita or their team. Thank you so much for all the hard work you have done for us.
Tricia Wheatstone
For almost 18 months I have been a client of Alex Ilkin. Alex is very knowledgeable and professional and has consistently provided me with thorough, honest and well set out advice, including steering my case through appeal proceedings. He always worked for my best interests with integrity and compassion. I recommend Alex and his team at PBL.

Latest insights & Practical Guides

Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.

We will call you within 24 hours.

How Can Our Expert Lawyers Help?

Strata Law

Property and strata disputes, building defects claims, setting up new Owners Corporations and more…

Construction & Building Law

Construction and building disputes, building defects, delays and claims, debt recovery and more…

International Estate Planning

Cross-border estate planning, international wills and trusts, tax-efficient wealth transfer strategies and more…

Commercial & Business Law

Starting and scaling your business, banking and business financing, bankruptcy and insolvency and more…

Planning & Environment Law

Environment and planning regulation, land and environment court disputes, sub-divisions and more…

Wills & Estates

Creating, updating and contesting wills, estate planning and administration, probate applications and more…

Thank You For Your Request.

We’ve received your consultation request and will contact you within the next 24 hours (excluding weekends).

Jye Hall
Anita Bradley has been an absolute dream to deal with. Anita's conveyancing skills and knowledge knows absolutely no boundaries along with her effective communication skills which has made selling and buying a completely stress free exchange for us. We recommend PBL Law to everyone looking for outstanding service. We will definitely be returning clients.
Kushlan Aluwihare
PBL Law Group were fantastic. Anita from PBL worked with us closely during our property search and made the exchange and settlement process smooth and stress free. Highly recommended.
Gail Whitford
PBL handled my late mothers estate, they were very obliging and patient with any and all questions that we had, thank you to David , Sharon and the other staff that we dealt with, everyone was so easy to talk to and friendly .David came to the home where my Mother was living and helped her to get her will in order, Sharon helped us through the process of executing her wishes when the time came even doing a house call which was so much easier, thank you all so much
S M
I have experienced an excellent service from PBL (especially from Anita) during the sale of my recent property on Central Coast, and during the purchase of our current property in Sydney. Throughout many challengers, especially with the sale, Anita presented her very professional and knowledgeable conveyancer, positively solving all obstacles. "Above and Beyond" Award going to Anita!!! :-)
Amanda Reitzin
The five-star reviews are well-deserved. I needed a motion and a bylaw drawn up for urgent repairs of my strata unit and the AGM was in two weeks' time. My solicitor was friendly, efficient, knew what documents to ask for, and had all the paperwork prepared well within the timeframe. She also took the time to run through all the legalese and the different possible scenarios with me to make sure I understood. I am so glad to have found this firm and I will not hesitate to use their services again in future if the need arises.
Ricky Cooper
Anita is amazing! So attentive, approachable and communicates everything every step of the way. I have now bought and sold property with Anita and I cannot recommend her highly enough.
Ron Thomsen
Our Commercial Property conveyancing was handled very professionally. Anita’s experience and responsiveness was an asset in this transaction.
Trace M
I am so grateful for Anita Bradley from PBL Law Group helped me with this property settlement, she has went above beyond to ensure I understand everything because of our deafness. I will recommended Anita or their team. Thank you so much for all the hard work you have done for us.
Tricia Wheatstone
For almost 18 months I have been a client of Alex Ilkin. Alex is very knowledgeable and professional and has consistently provided me with thorough, honest and well set out advice, including steering my case through appeal proceedings. He always worked for my best interests with integrity and compassion. I recommend Alex and his team at PBL.