Contesting a will in New South Wales (NSW) is a legal process where an eligible person challenges the validity of a deceased person’s will. This comprehensive guide explores the key legal grounds for challenging a will in NSW, including lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, and the process involved, including time limits and potential outcomes.

Understanding the legal grounds for contesting a will and the process involved is crucial for anyone who believes a will is invalid or does not adequately provide for them. This guide aims to provide clarity on these complex legal matters, empowering individuals to make informed decisions regarding deceased estates.

Grounds for Challenging the Validity of a Will in NSW

There are several legal grounds on which a will can be challenged in New South Wales (NSW). These grounds are rooted in the principle that a will should reflect the genuine and informed wishes of the deceased.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

A will is considered invalid if the will-maker, also known as the testator, lacked testamentary capacity at the time the will was made. Testamentary capacity refers to the mental ability to understand the nature and effect of making a will. To have testamentary capacity, the will-maker must:

• Understand they are making a will and what a will does.
• Remember the nature and extent of their property.
• Understand who they have a moral obligation to provide for, such as family members.
• Be free from any mental disorders or delusions that could influence their decisions.

For instance, if a person made a will while experiencing a severe mental health episode that impaired their judgment, and this could be corroborated by medical evidence, the will might be challenged on the grounds of lack of testamentary capacity.

Undue Influence

Undue influence occurs when a person is coerced or pressured into making a will that benefits the influencer or a third party. This pressure must be more than mere persuasion; it must be significant enough to overpower the will-maker’s free will. Evidence of coercion, threats, or manipulation could be used to prove undue influence.

Imagine a scenario where an elderly person, dependent on a caregiver, suddenly changes their will to favour the caregiver, excluding their family. If there is evidence of the caregiver manipulating or pressuring the elderly person, the will might be challenged on the grounds of undue influence.

Fraud or Forgery

A will is invalid if it is proven to be a forgery or obtained through fraudulent means. Forgery involves creating a false will or altering an existing one without the will-maker’s consent. Fraud encompasses any deceitful act intended to mislead the will-maker into signing a will they don’t understand or agree with.

If, for example, it is discovered that the signature on a will is not that of the deceased, or if a beneficiary is found to have deliberately misled the will-maker about the contents of the will, the will could be challenged on the grounds of fraud or forgery.

Lack of Knowledge and Approval

For a will to be valid, the will-maker must have knowledge of and approve its contents. This means they must understand what is in the will and agree to its provisions. If a will is prepared without the will-maker’s knowledge of its contents, or if they are misled about what it contains, the will can be challenged.

Consider a case where a will is prepared by a family member who includes provisions that benefit themselves, without explaining these provisions to the will-maker. If it can be proven that the will-maker did not know about these provisions, the will might be challenged on the grounds of lack of knowledge and approval.

Process of Challenging a Will in NSW

Contesting a will in New South Wales follows a structured legal process. This section provides a step-by-step guide to help you understand how to challenge a will in NSW.

Determining Eligibility to Challenge

Not everyone can challenge a will. The Succession Act 2006 (NSW) outlines specific individuals considered eligible to contest a will. These typically include:

• Spouses: This includes legally married partners and, in many cases, de facto partners who meet certain criteria.
• Children: Biological and adopted children generally have the right to contest a will.
• Dependents: Individuals who were financially or otherwise dependent on the deceased may be eligible to challenge the will.
• Beneficiaries of Previous Wills: Someone who was named as a beneficiary in a previous will but was excluded or received less in a later will might be eligible to challenge.

Time Limits for Contesting a Will

In NSW, strict time limits apply to will contests. Generally, you must initiate a challenge within 12 months of the deceased person’s death. Failing to act within this timeframe can significantly hinder your chances of success. However, the court has the discretion to extend this period under certain circumstances, such as if you were unaware of the death or were facing extenuating circumstances.

Filing a Probate Caveat

A crucial step in contesting a will is filing a ‘probate caveat’ with the Supreme Court of NSW. This legal document effectively prevents the court from granting probate, a process that confirms the will’s validity and allows the executor to distribute the estate’s assets. Filing a caveat buys you time to gather evidence and build your case.

Commencing Court Proceedings

If negotiations fail, and you decide to proceed with the challenge, you must initiate formal court proceedings. This involves filing a ‘Statement of Claim’ with the court, outlining the grounds for your challenge and the outcome you seek. The other parties involved in the dispute will then have the opportunity to respond to your claim, and the matter may proceed to a court hearing.

Evidence Required to Challenge a Will

Successfully challenging a will in NSW relies on presenting compelling evidence to the court. The type of evidence required directly correlates to the grounds on which the will is being challenged.

Medical Evidence for Lack of Testamentary Capacity

When a will is contested on the grounds of lack of testamentary capacity, medical evidence is paramount. This type of evidence aims to demonstrate that the testator, at the time of the will’s execution, did not possess the mental capacity to understand the nature and consequences of their actions. Medical records, doctor’s notes, and expert testimony from medical professionals can provide insights into the testator’s mental state during the relevant period. For instance, if a testator had been diagnosed with cognitive impairment, medical evidence could be used to argue that they lacked the capacity to make sound decisions regarding their estate.

Proving Undue Influence

Proving undue influence can be more complex than demonstrating a lack of testamentary capacity. Undue influence implies that the testator was coerced or manipulated into making a will that did not reflect their true wishes. Evidence in such cases might include financial records, correspondence, or witness testimonies that suggest a pattern of manipulation or control exerted by a third party. For example, if a caregiver consistently pressured the testator to include them in the will, and there was a sudden and significant change in the will’s provisions in the caregiver’s favour, this could be considered evidence of undue influence.

Expert Testimony for Fraud or Forgery Claims

Allegations of fraud or forgery require concrete evidence to substantiate the claim. Expert testimony often plays a crucial role in these cases. Handwriting experts can analyse the signatures on the will to determine their authenticity. Forensic document examiners can examine the will for signs of tampering or alteration. In cases of fraud, evidence might include financial transactions or communications that indicate an intention to deceive or mislead the testator for personal gain. Forgery, on the other hand, would necessitate evidence directly related to the creation or alteration of the will itself.

Role of Mediation in Will Disputes

This section will explore the importance of mediation in resolving will dispute, as it is a mandatory step in the process in NSW.

Benefits of Mediation

Mediation offers a structured environment for open communication and negotiation, guided by a neutral third party. This can be less adversarial than court proceedings, potentially preserving family relationships during a sensitive time.

The Mediation Process

In a will contest mediation, parties typically meet with a mediator, often a trained legal professional, to discuss their concerns and desired outcomes. The mediator facilitates communication, helping parties explore potential solutions and reach a mutually agreeable resolution. If an agreement is reached, it can be documented and, if necessary, submitted to the court for approval.

Potential Outcomes of Challenging a Will

Invalidation of the Will

If a will is successfully challenged in NSW and the court declares it invalid, the deceased person’s estate will be distributed as if the will never existed. This usually means the estate will be divided according to the rules of intestacy outlined in the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). For example, if the deceased had a previous valid will, the terms of that earlier document would dictate the distribution of assets.

Partial Amendments to the Will

In some situations, a will challenge might not result in the entire will being deemed invalid. Instead, the court may choose to amend specific parts of the will that are deemed problematic or contested. This could involve changing the distribution of certain assets or altering provisions that are deemed to be a result of undue influence or lack of testamentary capacity.

Distribution According to Intestacy Laws

If a will is invalidated and no prior valid will exists, the deceased’s estate will be distributed according to the intestacy laws of NSW. These laws provide a predetermined formula for how assets should be divided among close family members, starting with spouses and children, and then extending to other relatives depending on the family structure.

Costs Associated with Challenging a Will

Contesting a will in NSW can be an expensive process. The costs associated with challenging a will can vary depending on a number of factors, such as the complexity of the case, the length of the court proceedings, and whether the matter is settled out of court.

Legal Fees and Court Costs

The main costs associated with challenging a will are legal fees and court costs. Legal fees are the fees charged by solicitors and barristers for their services. Court costs are the fees charged by the court for filing documents, issuing subpoenas, and other court-related expenses.

Who Pays the Costs?

In most cases, the costs of a successful challenge to a will are paid out of the estate. This means that the beneficiaries of the estate will receive less than they would have if the will had not been challenged. However, the court has the discretion to order that the costs be paid by one of the parties to the proceedings. For example, if the court finds that a challenge to a will is frivolous or vexatious, it may order the person who brought the challenge to pay the costs of all parties.

Conclusion

Challenging a will in NSW is a complex legal process. It requires a clear understanding of the legal grounds, the evidence required, and the procedural steps involved. Navigating this process can be emotionally challenging, especially during a time of grief and loss.

This article has provided a comprehensive overview of the key aspects of contesting a will in NSW. However, it is essential to remember that this information is for general knowledge and should not be considered a substitute for professional legal advice. If you are considering challenging a will, seeking guidance from an experienced estate lawyer is crucial to protect your rights and navigate the complexities of the legal system.

Get the legal clarity you need. Schedule your consultation with us today.

Frequently Asked Questions