Introduction
Disputes are a common part of life within strata schemes in New South Wales, often arising from the shared nature of common property ownership and community living. Following the implementation of the Strata Schemes Legislation Amendment Act 2025 (NSW), understanding the evolving legal landscape is essential for lot owners and owners corporations to maintain harmony and ensure compliance.
This guide provides a practical framework for navigating the strata mediation process facilitated by NSW Fair Trading. Under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), attempting mediation is a mandatory step for most disputes before they can be escalated to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, making thorough preparation vital for a successful resolution.
Interactive Tool: Check If You Must Mediate & When to Apply to NCAT
Strata Mediation Readiness Checker
Determine if your strata dispute requires mandatory mediation or if you are eligible to proceed directly to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).
What is the primary subject of your strata dispute?
First Steps: Understanding the Role & Requirements of Strata Mediation
The Purpose & Benefits of Mediating Your Strata Dispute
Mediation is a valuable tool for resolving disputes within strata communities, serving as an informal negotiation process guided by a neutral mediator. The primary goal is to help all parties reach a mutually beneficial settlement. This is especially useful in community living situations where ongoing relationships are important. Furthermore, NSW Fair Trading provides this service free of charge.
Participating in mediation offers a significant opportunity to improve your living situation and foster a better understanding among residents. The key benefits of this process include:
- Cost-Effectiveness: The mediation service offered by NSW Fair Trading is free, although you are responsible for personal costs like legal advice or expert reports.
- Informal Setting: It provides a less adversarial environment than a formal tribunal, encouraging open and respectful communication.
- Improved Relationships: The process can help rebuild relationships between neighbours and improve the overall function of your strata community.
- Empowered Resolutions: It allows parties to have control over the outcome and find a solution that works for everyone, rather than having a decision imposed by a tribunal.
When Strata Mediation is a Compulsory First Step
Under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), attempting mediation is a mandatory first step for most strata disputes before they can be escalated to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). This requirement encourages parties to resolve their issues amicably without resorting to formal legal proceedings.
According to Section 227 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), the NCAT Registrar generally cannot accept an application to resolve a dispute unless one of the following conditions has been met:
- Mediation has been attempted but was ultimately unsuccessful.
- One of the parties involved has refused to participate in the mediation process.
- The Registrar considers mediation to be unnecessary or inappropriate for the specific circumstances of the dispute.
Common Strata Disputes Resolved Through Mediation
Mediation is particularly well-suited for a wide range of common issues that arise in strata schemes. By facilitating discussion in a structured setting, it allows parties to address their concerns and work towards a mutually agreeable outcome.
Matters that are often effectively resolved through mediation include:
- Repairs and Maintenance: Disagreements over the upkeep of common property, such as when an owners corporation fails to repair common property defects.
- Water Penetration: Conflicts related to leaks, drainage, or water damage affecting the building.
- By-Laws: Disputes concerning the interpretation, enforcement, or creation of strata by-laws.
- Noise and Parking: Issues arising from excessive noise or unauthorised parking on common property.
- Pets: Disagreements regarding the keeping of pets within the strata scheme.
- Alterations to Common Property: Conflicts over modifications or additions, such as the installation of air conditioners.
- Insurance Matters: Disputes involving insurance coverage, claims, or policies.
Conversely, certain matters are not suitable for mediation and can be taken directly to NCAT. These include:
- Applications for the appointment of a compulsory strata managing agent.
- Disputes over the allocation of unit entitlements.
- Issues regarding access to strata records.
Speak to a Lawyer Today.
We respond within 24 hours.
A Step-by-Step Guide to Preparing Your Strata Case
How to Lodge Your Strata Mediation Application
The first step in the formal mediation process is to submit an application to NSW Fair Trading. Although the form is completed online and usually takes about 15 minutes, you cannot save your progress, so it pays to have everything on hand before you start.
To complete the application, you will need to provide several key details, including:
- Your personal contact information.
- The details of the other person or parties involved in the dispute.
- Your strata plan number.
- Any supporting documents you wish to attach to strengthen your case.
Preparing Your Evidence with Expert Reports & Documentation
Being fully prepared for your mediation session is essential, and this means bringing every piece of relevant evidence that supports your position. Plans, documents and photographs can all be invaluable on the day.
For strata disputes over building defects, such as water ingress, an expert report is crucial. Before attending mediation, make sure the report:
- Clearly identifies the source of the problem.
- Specifies the exact location of the issue.
- Outlines a plan for the required work.
- Notes critical inspection stages during the repair process.
It is also helpful to gather other forms of evidence:
- Photos of any damage to illustrate the problem.
- Records of communication with the strata manager.
- Quotes from contractors detailing the cost of repairs.
Preparing Your Desired Outcomes & Settlement Terms
When lodging your application, it is highly beneficial to set out the settlement terms you are seeking. Doing so creates a clear starting point for negotiations and shows you have thought through a resolution.
For instance, you might propose that the owners corporation agrees to:
- Carry out the repairs as specified in the expert report.
- Ensure the work is inspected by a qualified consultant at key stages.
- Complete all repairs by a specific deadline.
- Provide compensation for losses such as reduced rent or the costs of legal and expert services.
Get legal advice you can rely on.
Contact us today.
Preparing for the Mediation Session Itself
Understanding the Mediator’s Role & the Session’s Structure
The mediation service offered by NSW Fair Trading is facilitated by an independent and neutral mediator. Their primary role is not to make decisions or determine who is right or wrong, but to guide the conversation and help the parties involved in the strata dispute find a mutually acceptable resolution.
The mediator is a skilled facilitator who ensures the process is fair and productive. Their key responsibilities include:
- Helping all parties identify the core issues of the dispute.
- Ensuring each person has an equal opportunity to speak and be heard.
- Keeping the discussion focused, respectful, and constructive.
- Assisting participants in exploring different options and strategies for settlement.
The mediation session itself follows a structured yet flexible format, typically lasting two to three hours. These sessions are often conducted online or by phone.
Each party begins by briefly describing the dispute from their perspective and outlining what they hope to achieve. The mediator then facilitates a discussion to explore the issues in more detail, encouraging negotiation and communication to help the parties reach an agreement.
Knowing Who Will Attend & the Rules of Engagement
It is important that all relevant people involved in the strata dispute attend the mediation session. This may include:
- The lot owner.
- A representative from the strata committee.
- The strata manager.
The goal is to have everyone present who has the authority to agree to a settlement.
Legal representation is not a standard part of the process. A solicitor may only be present if all other parties involved in the mediation give their approval in advance.
If required, the mediator can also arrange for an interpreter to attend the session to assist with communication.
Speak to a Lawyer Today.
We respond within 24 hours.
Preparing for All Potential Strata Mediation Outcomes
How to Prepare for a Successful Agreement
When all parties in a strata dispute find common ground during mediation, the mediator will help document the terms of the agreement in writing. This written record serves as a clear outline of what was decided during the session.
It is important to prepare for this outcome by understanding that this initial agreement is not automatically legally binding.
To ensure the resolution is enforceable, the parties can choose to formalise it. For example, the settlement can be made into a binding order, such as a consent order, through the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) if all parties agree to this step.
Understanding Your Next Steps if Strata Mediation is Unsuccessful
If a resolution is not achieved through mediation, you should be prepared for the next step in the strata dispute process. Unresolved matters may proceed to be heard at the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).
Failing to reach an agreement means that either party can apply to NCAT to have the matter formally determined. This involves a more structured legal process, and it is recommended that you seek legal advice to understand:
- What is required to file an application.
- How to prepare your case for a tribunal hearing.
Conclusion
Mediation presents a valuable and often mandatory first step for resolving a wide range of strata disputes in NSW, offering a more efficient and less confrontational alternative to formal NCAT proceedings. Success in mediation hinges on thorough preparation, including gathering comprehensive evidence and clearly outlining your desired settlement terms.
Given the complexities involved, seeking guidance from experienced NSW strata lawyers can significantly improve your position and the likelihood of a favourable outcome. Contact PBL Law Group’s experienced strata dispute lawyers for expert assistance in preparing for mediation and navigating your strata dispute effectively.
