Introduction

In New South Wales, when someone dies, an executor takes charge of sorting out the person’s belongings as per their will. This job can include looking after and selling the things they owned. Once the Supreme Court of NSW grants probate, the executor gets the legal power needed to handle everything in the estate.

Beneficiaries of a will may sometimes want to understand their rights when an executor decides to sell estate property. While executors have the authority to administer the estate and sell property, they also have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. This guide aims to clarify the balance between an executor’s authority to sell property and the rights beneficiaries have in relation to the administration of the estate.

The Role of the Executor and the Rights of Beneficiaries

Executor’s Fiduciary Duty to Beneficiaries

Executors have a fiduciary duty to beneficiaries, establishing a fundamental relationship of trust. This duty involves managing the estate’s assets and administering the estate for the beneficiaries’ benefit.

Right to Information and Estate Documents

Beneficiaries have the right to access information about the estate administration. Estate documents are considered the property of the beneficiaries, and executors should not deny access to these documents.

To effectively monitor the estate administration, beneficiaries need information on:

• Estate assets and liabilities: Understanding the nature and extent of the estate’s assets and debts.
• Distribution plans: Executors must disclose how they intend to distribute the estate’s assets.
• Estate documents: Viewing estate documents ensures transparency in the executor’s actions.

The extent of information a beneficiary is entitled to depends on their interest in the estate.

Executor’s Duty to Communicate and Account

Executors must maintain effective communication with beneficiaries throughout the estate administration process. To avoid conflicts and ensure transparency, executors must inform beneficiaries about significant decisions and provide regular financial updates. Open communication helps prevent misunderstandings and potential legal disputes.

If communication is lacking, beneficiaries have the right to seek further action to obtain necessary information. They can approach the court to compel the executor to provide relevant information if it is being withheld.

Executor’s Authority to Sell Estate Property in NSW

Probate and Legal Authority

In NSW, an executor requires legal authority to sell property from a deceased estate. This authority is granted through a process called probate. Probate is a formal legal document issued by the Supreme Court of NSW, which confirms the executor’s authority to:

• Administer the estate
• Manage and deal with the deceased person’s assets

An executor must obtain a grant of probate before they can legally sell estate property. Without probate, the executor does not have the legal standing to transfer ownership of the property. Therefore, obtaining a grant of probate is a necessary first step for an executor to manage and sell real property within the deceased estate.

Executor’s Power to Manage and Sell Assets

Once probate has been granted, an executor in NSW has broad powers to manage and administer the estate assets, including the authority to sell property. This power is essential for the executor to effectively administer the estate and distribute assets to the beneficiaries according to the will.

An executor has the right to:

• Call in the assets of the estate, which includes real estate
• Make decisions about selling estate property

The executor may need to sell property to manage the estate effectively, such as to:

• Pay off debts
• Settle other estate liabilities

Before distributing the remaining assets to the beneficiaries. The executor’s power to sell estate property is a key aspect of their role in administering the estate and carrying out the wishes of the deceased as outlined in the will.

Situations Where a Beneficiary Generally Cannot Stop a Property Sale

Executor Following Will Terms

Beneficiaries generally cannot prevent the sale of estate property if the executor is acting according to the will’s instructions. Often, a will directs the executor to:

• Sell assets not specifically gifted to a beneficiary
• Use the proceeds to settle debts
• Distribute the remaining estate to the beneficiaries

In these cases, the will-maker typically intends for the property to be sold to fulfill these objectives. Therefore, if the executor is selling property to follow these express terms within the will, a beneficiary usually cannot stop the sale.

Sale to Settle Estate Debts and Expenses

Executors may need to sell estate property to pay for the deceased’s debts, testamentary expenses, and estate administration costs. These liabilities can include:

• Loans
• Taxes
• Funeral expenses
• Court costs
• Legal fees

If the estate lacks sufficient cash assets to cover these necessary payments, the executor has the authority and may be required to sell property to generate funds. Beneficiaries cannot stop a sale of property when it is reasonably required for the executor to settle these legitimate estate debts and expenses.

Limited Circumstances Where a Beneficiary Can Potentially Stop a Property Sale

Undervalue Sale and Breach of Fiduciary Duty

A beneficiary may be able to seek a court order to stop the sale of estate property if they believe the executor is selling it below market value. Executors have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries and the estate. This duty requires them to manage estate assets responsibly and obtain a fair market value when selling property.

If a beneficiary believes that the executor is breaching their fiduciary duty by selling property at an undervalue, they can take the following actions:

• Hold the Executor Personally Responsible: A beneficiary can hold the executor accountable if they permit the sale of property below market value.
• Seek Legal Advice: To prevent an undervalue sale, a beneficiary may consult a legal professional.
• Apply to the Court: Beneficiaries can apply to the court for an order to stop the sale.

Court Intervention and Executor Misconduct

The Supreme Court of NSW has the authority to intervene and overrule an executor’s decisions, including the sale of estate property. If there is evidence of executor misconduct or mismanagement, or if the sale is not in the best interests of the estate, the court can stop the sale. Misconduct can include situations where the executor is not acting in accordance with their fiduciary duties or is mismanaging the assets of the estate.

In cases of misconduct, a beneficiary can take the following steps:

• Obtain a Court Order to Halt the Sale: The beneficiary can request the court to stop the sale based on evidence of misconduct.
• Compel Documentation: The court can require the executor to provide documentation regarding their administration of the estate.
• Refrain from Specific Actions: The court can order the executor to refrain from certain actions related to the estate.
• Remove the Executor: In serious instances of misconduct, the court has the power to remove the executor from their position.

Seeking Legal Advice

Importance of Legal Counsel for Executors

Executors managing deceased estates should seek legal advice from solicitors to navigate the complexities of estate administration and property sales. Solicitors provide essential guidance on duties and responsibilities, ensuring executors understand their legal obligations throughout the estate administration process.

Legal counsel is particularly important for executors in several key areas:

• Understanding Executor Duties: Solicitors clarify the full scope of an executor’s legal and fiduciary duties to act in the best interests of the estate and beneficiaries. This includes managing estate assets responsibly and transparently.
• Probate Process: Legal professionals guide executors through the probate process, which is necessary to obtain the legal authority to sell estate property in NSW. They assist with preparing and lodging the probate application with the Supreme Court of NSW.
• Legal Requirements for Property Sales: Solicitors advise on the specific legal requirements for selling estate property, ensuring that all sales are conducted in compliance with relevant legislation.
• Managing Beneficiary Expectations and Disputes: Legal advice helps executors manage communication with beneficiaries, address potential disputes, and navigate sensitive situations, such as selling a family home. Solicitors can also advise on strategies to maintain effective communication and transparency to minimise conflicts.

Importance of Legal Counsel for Beneficiaries

Beneficiaries also benefit significantly from seeking independent legal advice to understand their rights and protect their interests throughout estate administration. A solicitor can help beneficiaries navigate the complexities of estate law and ensure executors are fulfilling their duties appropriately.

Legal counsel is crucial for beneficiaries in the following situations:

• Understanding Beneficiary Rights: Solicitors can explain a beneficiary’s rights to information about the estate, including estate assets, liabilities, and the executor’s administration of the estate. This ensures beneficiaries are fully informed about the estate’s position.
• Challenging Executor Decisions: If a beneficiary believes that an executor is not acting in the best interests of the estate or is breaching their fiduciary duties, legal advice is essential. Solicitors can advise on the grounds for challenging an executor’s decisions, including concerns about undervalue sales of estate property.
• Ensuring Interests are Protected: Legal professionals can assist beneficiaries in ensuring their interests are protected during estate administration and property sales. This includes advising on the beneficiary’s right to seek court intervention if necessary to stop a property sale or address executor misconduct.
• Resolving Disputes: In cases of disputes with the executor or other beneficiaries, legal counsel can provide representation and guidance to resolve conflicts effectively. This may involve negotiation, mediation, or court proceedings to protect the beneficiary’s entitlement.

Conclusion

In summary, executors in NSW possess the authority to administer deceased estates, which includes the sale of property once probate is granted. Executors are bound by a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. Beneficiaries, on the other hand, have specific rights to be informed and receive communication concerning the administration of the estate. While executors are empowered to sell property in accordance with the will or to settle estate debts, beneficiaries possess limited avenues to impede a sale, typically in instances of undervalue sales or executor misconduct. In navigating these complexities, seeking legal advice is paramount for both executors and beneficiaries.

For beneficiaries and executors seeking clarity and expert assistance navigating estate administration and property sales, PBL Legal’s experienced solicitors offer specialised legal advice to protect your interests and ensure compliance with all legal obligations. Reach out to PBL Legal today to book a consultation and benefit from our proven solutions in estate law.

Frequently Asked Questions