Executor & Trustee Disputes: A Guide to Conflicts of Interest & Mismanagement

Key Takeaways

  • Fiduciary duty: Executors must act honestly, impartially and in the best interests of beneficiaries, keeping full accounts; breach can lead to personal liability and court‑ordered removal.
  • Executor’s year: Estates should be administered within 12 months of death; unreasonable delays undermine any removal claim and increase costs.
  • Resolution routes: Start with transparent communication and accurate records, then pursue mediation; if unresolved, file an application in the Supreme Court with evidence to remove the executor and appoint a replacement.
  • Risk of conflict of interest: Any self‑dealing or personal gain creates a serious conflict that may result in removal and liability, so avoid transactions that benefit the executor over the estate.
7 min read
Jump to...

Introduction

Serving as an executor or trustee is a critical responsibility, ensuring a deceased person’s final wishes are honoured through proper estate administration. However, this role is often complex and can become a legal minefield, particularly when claims of mismanagement or conflicts of interest arise between the executor and beneficiaries, potentially causing significant delays and distress.

This guide offers essential guidance for both executors and beneficiaries navigating these challenging situations. It provides a clear framework for understanding an executor’s duties, identifying potential misconduct, and outlining the steps that can be taken to prevent or resolve disputes, ensuring the estate is managed fairly and effectively.

Understanding an Executor’s Core Duties & Legal Obligations

The Fiduciary Duty to Act in the Best Interests of Beneficiaries

An executor’s relationship with the beneficiaries of an estate is fiduciary. This means the executor, acting as a trustee, has a legal obligation to act honestly and prioritise the best interests of the beneficiaries above their own, which is a key component of the rights as a beneficiary.

This duty forms the foundation of their role and requires them to manage the estate with impartiality and fairness.

Key Responsibilities During Estate Administration

During the estate administration process, an executor is tasked with several critical responsibilities, making it essential to understand the full scope of the duties of an executor of a will to carry out the deceased’s wishes. Fulfilling these duties diligently is essential for a smooth and lawful distribution of the estate.

The primary responsibilities of an executor include:

ResponsibilityDescription
Arranging the funeralHandling the disposal of the deceased’s body in accordance with their wishes.
Securing a Grant of ProbateLegally validating the will through the court by securing a Grant of Probate, which authorises the executor to manage the estate.
Identifying & collecting assetsValuing all estate assets accurately and ensuring they are secured until distribution.
Paying debts & taxesSettling all outstanding debts and taxes, which must be completed before distributing assets to beneficiaries.
Keeping detailed recordsMaintaining accurate records of all financial transactions, decisions, and communications related to the estate.
Distributing assetsDistributing the assets to the beneficiaries strictly according to the terms outlined in the will.
Maintaining communicationKeeping beneficiaries informed about the progress of the estate administration.

Common Examples of Executor Mismanagement & Misconduct

Financial Mismanagement & Misappropriation of Estate Assets

One of the most serious forms of executor misconduct is the misappropriation of estate assets—a key example of executor fraud—which occurs when an executor uses estate funds or property for their own personal benefit. This is a significant breach of their fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries. Such actions can jeopardise the financial health of the estate and erode trust among all parties involved.

Examples of financial mismanagement include:

Example of MismanagementDescription
Using estate funds for personal usePaying personal bills or transferring money from the estate to personal accounts.
Selling assets below market valueConducting transactions that may benefit the executor or an associate rather than the estate.
Engaging in self-dealingAn executor selling an estate asset, such as a property, to themselves, creating a clear conflict of interest.

Executors are also legally required to maintain clear and accurate records of all financial transactions related to the estate. A failure to keep proper accounts can be a sign of negligence or, in some cases, may be an attempt to conceal deliberate misconduct.

Beneficiaries who suspect financial mismanagement have the right to request a full accounting of the estate’s transactions.

Failures in Administrative Duties & Beneficiary Communication

Beyond financial misconduct, an executor can also breach their duties through administrative failures and poor communication. Unreasonable delays in the administration process are a common source of disputes.

While complex estates take time to finalise, courts generally recognise an informal guideline known as the “executor’s year,” which allows one year from the date of death to administer the estate. If an executor exceeds this timeframe, they must be able to provide a valid reason for the delay.

Other administrative failures that constitute misconduct include:

  • Ignoring the terms of the will, such as disregarding specific instructions about how assets should be distributed or failing to honour particular bequests
  • Failing to communicate with beneficiaries, which involves not providing regular updates on the estate’s progress or withholding important information

Poor communication can cause anxiety and suspicion, potentially hiding more serious issues. Additionally, disagreements can arise over how to manage the estate, such as whether to sell certain assets or which debts to prioritise.

An executor must act impartially and make decisions that benefit the estate as a whole, rather than favouring their own interests or those of a specific beneficiary.

Managing Executor Conflicts of Interest

What Constitutes a Conflict of Interest in Estate Administration

A conflict of interest arises when an executor’s personal interests interfere with their fiduciary duty to act impartially and in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries. While an executor can also be a beneficiary, difficulties emerge when their decisions could unfairly favour their own position over others.

The core of the issue is a clash between the executor’s personal benefit and their legal obligations to the estate. Several situations can create a serious conflict of interest that may jeopardise the proper administration of an estate. These scenarios often require careful management to avoid a dispute and potential legal challenges, such as an application to contest a will, from a beneficiary.

Common examples include:

Type of ConflictExplanation
Self-dealing with estate assetsAn executor selling an estate asset to themselves, especially below market value, which is a serious breach of duty.
Being a debtor to the estateThe executor’s personal interest in minimising a debt they owe to the deceased conflicts with their duty to collect all estate assets.
Prioritising personal gainMaking decisions that financially benefit the executor over other beneficiaries, such as delaying a property sale to purchase it later at a lower price.
Business or ownership disputesThe executor’s personal business dealings or ownership interests are not aligned with the best outcome for the estate, hindering neutral decisions.

When a Conflict of Interest May Not Justify an Executor’s Removal

The existence of a conflict of interest does not automatically guarantee that a court will remove an executor. The court’s primary focus is always on the welfare of the beneficiaries and ensuring the efficient and satisfactory administration of the estate.

A court will not lightly interfere with the deceased’s choice of executor unless there are compelling reasons to do so. In the case of Connock v Connock, the court decided against removing an executor who was prosecuting a personal claim against the estate. The decision was based on several factors that, when combined, showed that removal was not in the best interests of the beneficiaries.

The court may allow a conflicted executor to remain in their role by weighing specific circumstances, such as:

Factor Considered by the CourtExplanation
Finality of administrationIf the estate is largely finalised, appointing a new trustee may create unnecessary costs and delays with little benefit.
Nature of the conflictThe court assesses if the executor can unilaterally decide on their own claim; if the matter requires a court decision, the risk of prejudice is lower.
Cost of replacementThe court considers whether the costs of appointing a new executor would unfairly burden the residuary beneficiaries.
Wishes of other beneficiariesIf other beneficiaries are aware of the conflict and support the executor continuing, the court may take this into account.
Risk of further litigationRemoving an executor could lead to more legal proceedings if a new appointee is compelled to bring the same claim, causing further costs.

Proactive Strategies for Executors to Prevent Disputes

Maintain Transparent Communication & Keep Accurate Records

One of the most effective ways for an executor to prevent disputes is by maintaining open and honest communication with all beneficiaries. A lack of transparency can lead to distrust and conflict, so providing regular updates is crucial. To ensure transparent communication:

  • Share information about the estate’s progress regularly
  • Provide details on asset valuations and debt settlements
  • Address any concerns from beneficiaries promptly to prevent misunderstandings from escalating

Equally important is the need to keep meticulous and accurate records of all financial transactions and decisions related to the estate administration. This documentation serves as vital evidence to defend against any potential claims of mismanagement.

Key records to maintain include:

  • Bank statements and receipts for all payments
  • Property appraisals and valuations of other significant assets
  • All correspondence with beneficiaries, co-executors, and legal advisors

Act Impartially & Seek Professional Legal Advice

As an executor, you have a fiduciary duty to act impartially and in the best interests of the estate as a whole, rather than favouring your own interests or those of a specific beneficiary. You must avoid any conflicts of interest and make decisions that are fair and reasonable to build trust and prevent disputes. This includes not engaging in self-serving activities, such as purchasing estate assets without a proper valuation.

Handling an estate can be complex, and seeking professional guidance is a key strategy for minimising legal risks. Consulting with experienced estate lawyers ensures you:

  • Comply with all legal obligations
  • Navigate complex tax requirements
  • Manage any disagreements professionally

This approach significantly reduces the risk of personal liability for executors.

Use Mediation for Alternative Dispute Resolution

When disagreements do arise, mediation in NSW will disputes offers a constructive and cost-effective alternative to litigation.This form of alternative dispute resolution involves a neutral third party who works with the executor and beneficiaries to find a mutually acceptable solution. It is a less adversarial process than going to court and can help preserve family relationships.

Mediation is particularly useful for resolving issues before they become entrenched, such as:

  • Minor disagreements over the distribution of personal assets
  • Clarifying an executor’s decisions to beneficiaries
  • Reaching a compromise without the expense and stress of a legal battle

The Legal Process for Removing a Problematic Executor

Legal Grounds for Seeking an Executor’s Removal from an Estate

A court will not lightly interfere with a deceased person’s choice of executor, but it holds the power to remove an executor if their actions jeopardise the welfare of the beneficiaries or the proper administration of the estate. The court’s primary focus is always on ensuring the estate is managed efficiently and in the best interests of those who are to inherit.

Beneficiaries or co-executors may seek to have a problematic executor removed on several legal grounds. These grounds typically require evidence of serious failings rather than minor disagreements or reasonable delays.

Common reasons for a court to approve an executor’s removal include:

Legal Ground for RemovalDescription & Examples
Breach of duty or misconductIncludes serious failures such as mismanaging assets, selling property below market value for personal gain, or refusing to provide a proper financial accounting.
Serious conflict of interestArises when an executor’s personal interests clash with their duty to the estate, preventing them from acting impartially (e.g., being a debtor to the estate).
Unreasonable delaysSignificant and unjustifiable delays in administration, particularly beyond the informal “executor’s year,” without a valid reason.
Incapacity or inability to actThe executor becomes incapable of fulfilling their duties due to illness, loss of mental capacity, prolonged absence, or even the death of an executor.

How to Apply to the Court for Removal

If attempts to resolve issues through communication or mediation fail, an interested party, such as a beneficiary or co-executor, can apply to the Supreme Court to have a problematic executor removed. This legal process is considered a last resort and requires strong evidence to be successful.

The process for applying for an executor’s removal generally involves the following steps:

Step in the Removal ProcessDescription
1. Gathering EvidenceCollect clear evidence of misconduct, inaction, or conflict of interest, such as financial statements, correspondence, and a timeline of events.
2. Filing a Court ApplicationFile an application with the Supreme Court, supported by affidavits that explain why removal is necessary for the proper administration of the estate.
3. The Court HearingThe executor is given an opportunity to respond to the allegations, and a judge considers the evidence from both sides before making a decision.
4. Court OrdersIf the grounds for removal are met, the court will issue an order to remove the executor and may appoint a replacement to finalise the estate.

Conclusion

Fulfilling the role of an executor requires a clear understanding of fundamental legal duties while recognising the significant risks posed by mismanagement and conflicts of interest. This guide has detailed these core responsibilities and outlined the proactive strategies and legal processes available to prevent and resolve disputes, ensuring a fair and efficient estate administration.

If you are facing an executor dispute or require guidance to confidently manage your duties, contact PBL Law Group’s experienced wills and estates lawyers for specialised legal support. Our team provides the trusted expertise needed to navigate these complex situations and protect the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Loading

Loading

Last Updated on September 27, 2025
Jump to...

Rated 5-Star By Our Clients

Latest Insights & Practical Guides

Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.

We will call you within 24 hours.

How Can Our Expert Lawyers Help?

Strata Law

Property and strata disputes, building defects claims, setting up new Owners Corporations and more…

Construction & Building Law

Construction and building disputes, building defects, delays and claims, debt recovery and more…

International Estate Planning

Cross-border estate planning, international wills and trusts, tax-efficient wealth transfer strategies and more…

Commercial & Business Law

Starting and scaling your business, banking and business financing, bankruptcy and insolvency and more…

Planning & Environment Law

Environment and planning regulation, land and environment court disputes, sub-divisions and more…

Wills & Estates

Creating, updating and contesting wills, estate planning and administration, probate applications and more…

Book a 15-Min Consultation​

Thank You For Your Request.

We’ve received your consultation request and will contact you within the next 24 hours (excluding weekends).

Google 5-star review: Excellent