Can I Challenge an NCAT Strata Decision: Appealing an NCAT Decision in NSW
Introduction NCAT,or the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal,serves
NSW Court of Appeal Strata Dispute Lawyers
- Expert NSW Court of Appeal Representation.
- 50+ Years Success in Strata Disputes.
- Client-Focused, Plain-English Strategic Advice.
- Securing Favourable Outcomes in Complex Appeals.
Speak to a Lawyer Today
NSW Court of Appeal Strata Lawyers Assisting:
Strata Lot Owners
Appealing adverse NCAT or court decisions, advice on appeal prospects, representation in Court of Appeal & more...
Strata Lot Owners
New Owners Corporations
Guidance on appealing early adverse decisions, advice on complex appellate matters, Court of Appeal representation & more...
Owners Corporations
Developers
Appealing decisions on defect claims, advice on high-stakes appellate litigation, Court of Appeal representation & more...
Developers
Strata Managers
Supporting OCs in appellate proceedings, advice on Court of Appeal procedures, navigating complex appeal cases & more...
Strata Managers
Existing Owners Corporations
Appealing NCAT or court rulings, managing complex appellate litigation, representation in the Court of Appeal & more...
Existing Owners Corporations
Our Court of Appeal Strata Lawyers Help You Win in:
Strata NCAT Appeals & Defences in Higher Courts
Our experienced strata lawyers provide robust representation and strategic advice for lot owners and owners corporations in strata and NCAT appeals before the NSW Court of Appeal, vigorously protecting your interests.
Building Defect & Property Repair Claim Appeals & Defences
Specialising in NSW Court of Appeal cases for building defects and common property repair duties, our strata dispute lawyers effectively advance and protect your position by building persuasive arguments based on meticulous case reviews.
Strata By-Law Enforcement & Dispute Appeals & Defences
When by-law enforcement or disputes escalate to the NSW Court of Appeal, our strata lawyers provide expert legal services and champion your case concerning by-law interpretation or validity to positively impact your interests.
Strata Levy & Financial Dispute Appeals & Defences
For strata levy recovery or financial mismanagement disputes reaching the NSW Court of Appeal, our strata dispute lawyers deliver diligent, commercially astute legal assistance and compelling arguments to protect your financial position.
Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.
We will call you within 24 hours.
Our Winning Approach to Your Court of Appeal Case
1
Strategic Appeal Review & Expert Guidance
Our strata lawyers conduct a deep case review, advising on appeal prospects and identifying legal errors to develop winning strategies and empower your informed decisions.
Strategic Appeal Review & Expert Guidance
Our strata lawyers conduct a deep case review, advising on appeal prospects and identifying legal errors to develop winning strategies and empower your informed decisions.
2
Meticulous Preparation & Precise Court Filing
Our team meticulously prepares all essential court documents, from Notices of Appeal to complex applications, strictly adhering to Court of Appeal rules.
This precision ensures your case is filed flawlessly, ready for a powerful court presentation.
Meticulous Preparation & Precise Court Filing
Our team meticulously prepares and files all essential Court of Appeal documents, from Notices of Appeal to complex applications, ensuring precision and readiness for a powerful presentation.
3
Fierce Advocacy For Your Case in Court
Our skilled strata dispute lawyers deliver strong, persuasive advocacy before the NSW Court of Appeal, developing compelling arguments and adeptly countering opposition to achieve a favourable decision.
Fierce Advocacy For Your Case in Court
Our skilled strata dispute lawyers deliver strong, persuasive advocacy before the NSW Court of Appeal, developing compelling arguments and adeptly countering opposition to achieve a favourable decision.
4
Securing Your Win & Guiding Next Steps
Our support continues post-decision to ensure your success, assisting with implementing orders, negotiating settlements, and ensuring you fully grasp the outcome’s positive impact.
Securing Your Win & Guiding Next Steps
Our support continues post-decision to ensure your success, assisting with implementing orders, negotiating settlements, and ensuring you fully grasp the outcome’s positive impact.
Rated 5-Star By Our Clients
Why Choose PBL Law Group as Your NSW Court of Appeal Lawyers
Proven Success in Strata Appeals & Court Cases
Our strata dispute lawyers have a strong track record securing favourable outcomes in complex strata appeals across all NSW judicial levels, including the Court of Appeal.
Proven Success in Strata Appeals & Court Cases
Our strata dispute lawyers have a strong track record securing favourable outcomes in complex strata appeals across all NSW judicial levels, including the Court of Appeal.
Client-Focused & Commercially Sensitive Legal Advice
Our strata lawyers deliver clear, plain-English advice tailored to your Court of Appeal objectives, prioritising cost-effective strategies and your commercial needs.
Client-Focused & Commercially Sensitive Legal Advice
Our strata lawyers deliver clear, plain-English advice tailored to your Court of Appeal objectives, prioritising cost-effective strategies and your commercial needs.Our strata lawyers are committed to effective legal services tailored to your specific circumstances, understanding your objectives to offer clear plain-English advice.
We focus on cost-effective solutions and personalised attention, ensuring you’re fully informed with prompt communication throughout your case.
Integrated Expertise for Comprehensive Strata Solutions
We combine in-depth strata law with robust building, construction, and planning insights, allowing our strata lawyers to develop comprehensive strategies for your Court of Appeal matter.
Integrated Expertise for Comprehensive Strata Solutions
We combine in-depth strata law with robust building, construction, and planning insights, allowing our strata lawyers to develop comprehensive strategies for your Court of Appeal matter.
Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.
We will call you within 24 hours.
Strata Lawyers Sydney & NSW can Trust
Raea Khan
Partner & Director Lawyer
Iain Mark
Partner
Alex Ilkin
Principal Strata Lawyer
Sharon Banning
Senior Lawyer
Mark Stace
Senior Lawyer
Peggie Pantsos
Associate Lawyer
Overview of Strata Schemes and the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW)
A strata scheme involves ownership of a ‘lot’ and shared ‘common property’ through an owners corporation. The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) governs this.
Key appeal aspects include definitions of lots and common property, the owners corporation’s management role, its duty to maintain common property, by-laws, and owners’ rights and responsibilities.
Dispute resolution begins with mediation and NCAT, with appeals possible to higher courts on legal questions.
Common Strata Disputes Leading to Court of Appeal Litigation
Strata disputes can escalate to NCAT and the NSW Court of Appeal if unresolved, often involving complex legal issues.
Common types include building defects under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), owners corporation failures to maintain common property under Section 106 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), disputes over by-law interpretation, levy recovery actions, and conflicts over common property use.
Appeals from NCAT decisions are also common. Understanding strata law is crucial for potential litigation.
Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.
We will call you within 24 hours.
How Can Our Expert NSW Strata Lawyers Help?
Strata Building Defects
Building defects? We seek rectification and compensation for Owners Corporations and lot owners, safeguarding your investment.
Strata Building Defects
Building defects? We seek rectification and compensation for Owners Corporations and lot owners, safeguarding your investment.
Strata Dispute Resolution Advice & Representation
Resolving strata conflicts, from owner disagreements to OC disputes, with strategic advice for effective outcomes.
Strata Dispute Resolution Advice & Representation
Resolving strata conflicts, from owner disagreements to OC disputes, with strategic advice for effective outcomes.
Strata By-Laws Drafting, Reviewing & Enforcement
Crafting, reviewing and enforcing compliant by-laws for harmonious strata living and effective management.
Strata By-Laws Drafting, Reviewing & Enforcement
Crafting, reviewing and enforcing compliant by-laws for harmonious strata living and effective management.
Strata Property Development
Assisting developers with strata schemes, subdivisions, easements, and redevelopment projects.
Strata Property Development
Assisting developers with strata schemes, subdivisions, easements, and redevelopment projects.
Strata Levy Recovery
Ensure your Owners Corporation's financial stability by recovering unpaid levies and enforcing payment through effective legal strategies.
Strata Levy Recovery
Ensure your Owners Corporation’s financial stability by recovering unpaid levies and enforcing payment through effective legal strategies.
NCAT Strata Disputes
Expert representation at NCAT for strata disputes. Resolve issues like by-law breaches, repairs, and owner conflicts effectively.
NCAT Strata Disputes
Expert representation at NCAT for strata disputes. Resolve issues like by-law breaches, repairs, and owner conflicts effectively.
Strata Building Management Agreements
Expert advice on management & caretaker agreements. We draft & review to protect your scheme.
Strata Building Management Agreements
Expert advice on management & caretaker agreements. We draft & review to protect your scheme.
Strata Renewal
Expert advice for strata renewal & collective sale. We help owners maximise value and ensure compliance.
Strata Renewal
Expert advice for strata renewal & collective sale. We help owners maximise value and ensure compliance.
Supreme Court Strata Litigation
High-stakes strata litigation & appeals. Expert representation in the Supreme Court for complex disputes.
Supreme Court Strata Litigation
High-stakes strata litigation & appeals. Expert representation in the Supreme Court for complex disputes.
Expert Strata Insights & Practical Guides
How to Deal with Noise Problems in Strata Building?
Introduction Residents of strata buildings often encounter noise disturbances,which can
Strata Title or Torrens Title for My Newly Built Duplex Property in NSW?
Introduction If you’re considering buying or building a duplex in
Frequently Asked Questions About NSW Court of Appeal Lawyers and Strata Law Appeals
What types of strata disputes can be appealed to the NSW Court of Appeal?
A range of strata disputes can be appealed to the NSW Court of Appeal, typically on a question of law arising from an NCAT decision or a lower court judgment concerning the strata scheme. Common examples include disputes over the interpretation or enforcement of a by-law, claims related to building defects affecting common property, the recovery of unpaid levies, and disagreements regarding the owners corporation’s duty to maintain and repair common property. These matters often involve complex interpretations of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) and can significantly impact lot owners and the owners – strata plan.
How does the appeal process work in the NSW Court of Appeal?
The appeal process in the NSW Court of Appeal generally begins with an application for leave to appeal the decision of a tribunal like NCAT or a lower court, unless an appeal lies as of right. If leave is granted, the appellant files a Notice of Appeal, followed by the preparation and filing of written submissions and an appeal book containing relevant documents from the original proceeding. The process culminates in a court hearing where oral arguments are presented before the judges, leading to a final judgment on the appeal concerning the strata dispute.
When should I seek legal advice for a strata dispute or appeal?
You should seek legal advice for a strata dispute or potential appeal as early as possible, particularly if you are dissatisfied with a decision from NCAT or a lower court. Strict time limits apply for lodging appeals, and early consultation with a legal professional ensures these deadlines are met and allows for thorough case preparation and assessment of your prospects for the appeal proceeding. Obtaining legal advice promptly can significantly impact the effective management of your strata law matter in NSW.
What is the role of NCAT in strata disputes and how does it relate to the Court of Appeal?
NCAT serves as the primary specialist tribunal for resolving many strata disputes in NSW, offering mediation, adjudication, and formal hearings for matters arising under strata schemes management legislation. NCAT decisions on strata matters, particularly those involving an alleged error of law, can be subject to appeal, with leave, to the NSW Supreme Court and subsequently to the NSW Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal reviews NCAT’s decisions to ensure legal principles, including those under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), have been correctly applied to the strata plan.
Can PBL Law Group represent both lot owners and owners corporations?
Yes, PBL Law Group has extensive experience representing both individual lot owners and owners corporations in a wide range of strata disputes and appeal proceedings. Our law firm provides tailored legal advice and robust representation to all parties involved in strata scheme matters, including those before NCAT and the NSW Court of Appeal in Sydney. We understand the unique perspectives and legal issues faced by different stakeholders within a strata and community scheme.
What are common grounds for appealing a strata dispute decision?
Common grounds for appealing a strata dispute decision from NCAT or a lower court to the NSW Court of Appeal primarily involve demonstrating an error of law made by the original decision-maker in the proceeding. Other potential grounds for appeal include a denial of procedural fairness during the initial hearing, or that the decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable tribunal or court could have reached it based on the evidence. Successful appeal proceedings often require clearly showing that such an error materially affected the outcome of the strata dispute concerning the owners corporation or lot owner.
How does PBL Law Group ensure clear communication during appeal proceedings?
PBL Law Group ensures clear communication during appeal proceedings by providing all legal advice in plain English, avoiding overly technical jargon so that clients, whether a lot owner or an owners corporation, fully understand every aspect of their case. We are committed to providing regular updates and maintaining open lines of communication, ensuring you are kept informed about the progress of your appeal in the NSW Court of Appeal. Our client-focused approach means your legal professional is accessible to answer your questions throughout the litigation process regarding your strata scheme.
What is the duty of an owners corporation regarding maintenance and repair of common property?
An owners corporation has a strict statutory duty under section 106 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) to properly maintain and keep in a state of good and serviceable repair the common property and any personal property vested in the owners corporation. This obligation is fundamental to the management of a strata scheme and is a frequent subject of strata disputes if not adequately fulfilled by the owners corporation. Failure to comply with this duty to maintain and repair common property can lead to legal proceedings in NCAT or the courts, seeking orders for work to be done or damages.
How can PBL Law Group assist with building defect claims in strata schemes?
PBL Law Group can assist with building defect claims in strata schemes by providing expert legal advice on statutory warranties under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) and developing effective litigation strategies for the owners corporation or affected lot owners. We represent clients in pursuing or defending claims related to defective building work impacting a strata building, including navigating dispute resolution processes and, if necessary, proceedings in NCAT or the NSW Court of Appeal. Our team helps identify defects, understand your rights regarding common property, and pursue appropriate remedies for your strata property in NSW.
Expert Legal Help For All Your Needs
Strata Law
Property and strata disputes, building defects claims, setting up new Owners Corporations and more…
Construction & Building Law
Construction and building disputes, building defects, delays and claims, debt recovery and more…
International Estate Planning
Cross-border estate planning, international wills and trusts, tax-efficient wealth transfer strategies and more…
Commercial & Business Law
Starting and scaling your business, banking and business financing, bankruptcy and insolvency and more…
Planning & Environment Law
Environment and planning regulation, land and environment court disputes, sub-divisions and more…
Wills & Estates
Creating, updating and contesting wills, estate planning and administration, probate applications and more…
Speak to us Now or Request a Consultation.
We will call you within 24 hours.
Helpful Links
Site information
How We Can Help
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Copyright © 2025 PBL Law Group. All Rights Reserved
